| Create Your Own! |
| Your choice of our homemade sauces and any cheese. As always, our ricotta, parmesan, & garlic are available for no-charge; just ask!
Served with a side of our delicious tomato sauce.
|
individual Calzone $8 additional ingredients $1 |
| Cheesy |
| Fresh mozzarella, ricotta, parmesan, & sharp white cheddar with our delicious tomato sauce and organic minced garlic. |
$9 |
| Pesto |
| Pesto, organic yellow onions, organic baby spinach, vine-ripened roma tomatoes, ricotta & mozzarella. |
$9 |
| Pig in a Poke |
| Prosciutto di parma, pepperoni, grilled shrimp, pineapple, our tomato sauce, mozzarella & parmesan. |
$11 |
| Meat - Meat - Meat |
| Pepperoni, canadian bacon & italian sausage folded together w/monterey jack, mozzarella, parmesan & our homemade tomato sauce. |
$10 |
| Meatball |
| Our homemade, organic meatballs blended w/black olives, vine-ripened tomatoes, organic red onions, our tomato sauce, mozzarella & feta. |
$10 |
|
| Meat Lasagna |
| A delicious blend of fresh all-natural ground beef, our homemade tomato sauce, organic grilled onions, organic mushrooms, spices, ricotta, mozzarella, and parmesan.
Made with pure Semolina pasta.
Served with Your choice of Breadsticks OR a Side Salad! |
$11 |
| Vegetarian Lasagna |
| A spicy dish including organic broccoli, organic eggplant, organic baby spinach, organic grilled onions, organic mushrooms, chipotle peppers, our tomato sauce, ricotta, mozzarella, and parmesan.
Made with pure Semolina pasta.
Served with your choice of Breadsticks OR a Side Salad! |
$11 |
| Meatball Ravioli |
| Our homemade meatballs and cheese ravioli baked with our organic tomato sauce, minced garlic, mozzarella, white cheddar and parmesan. Served with a side salad! |
$11 |
| Chicken Pesto Ravioli |
| All-natural grilled chicken, sundried tomatoes, homemade pesto, minced garlic, mozzarella, white cheddar & parmesan baked with a healthy portion of cheese ravioli. Served with a side salad! |
$11 |
| Mushroom Ravioli |
| Portobello ravioli covered with our homemade cream of mushroom sauce, all-natural grilled chicken, mozzarella, white cheddar & parmesan. Served with a side salad! |
$12 |
| Cheese Manicotti |
| All natural cheese manicotti baked in our homemade tomato sauce with minced garlic, mozzarella, provolone & parmesan. Served with a side salad! |
$9 |
| Create Your Own |
| Make your own ravioli bake. Choose either a Four Cheese or Portobello Ravioli and add your favorite sauce. We'll add Mozzarella and Parmesan. Additional cheeses and toppings are $1. |
$6 |
|
| Create Your Own! |
| Enjoy a pie made just the way you want! Skilled hands prepare every pie to order and bake each of them on our stone hearth. Choose our traditional Thick or our Thin Crust. Both the dough and tomato sauce are handmade daily from the finest organic ingredients. Served with wisconsin, independently-farmed whole milk mozzarella. |
small $6.30, medium $10, large $13 additional toppings $1, $1.50, $2 |
| Five Point |
| Pesto, organic minced garlic, sundried tomatoes, mozzarella, parmesan & fontina cheeses |
$9.60, $15.40, $19.60 |
| the Aristocrat |
| Extra virgin olive oil, organic garlic, organic mushrooms, sharp white cheddar, mozzarella, roasted tomato slices, roasted yellow onions, organic roasted potatoes & parmesan |
$10.60, $16.80, $21.60 |
| Big Star |
| Homemade pesto, mozzarella, parmesan, gorgonzola, fontina, roasted red peppers & pistachios. |
$10.60, $16.80, $21.60 |
| Hawaiian Punch |
| Organic tomato sauce, mozzarella, sopressata, mandarin oranges, pineapples, parmesan & ricotta |
$9.60, $15.40, $19.60 |
| Dante's Inferno |
| Barbeuce sauce, mozzarella, all-natural barbecued chicken, bacon, organic red onions, roasted red peppers & parmesan |
$10.60, $16.80, $21.60 |
| South of the Border |
| Homemade black bean salsa, organic garlic, sharp white cheddar, monterey jack, all-natural grilled chicken, organic yellow onions, organic diced jalepenos, roasted chilies, our homemade atomic sauce & cilantro |
$11, $18, $23 |
| Mr. Green Jeans |
| Extra virgin olive oil, organic mushrooms, organic broccoli, mozzarella, vine-ripened roma tomatoes, organic red onions, black olives & organic fresh basil |
$10.60, $16.80, $21.60 |
| Super Duper |
| Homemade organic tomato sauce, monterey jack, sharp white cheddar, pepperoni, italian sausage, all-natural ground beef & bacon |
$10.6, $16.80, $21.60 |
| Corporate Greed |
| Homemade Alfredo, Organic Cremini Mushrooms, Mozzarella, Artichoke Hearts, All-Natural Grilled Chicken & Organic Yellow Onions with Parmesan |
$10.30, $16.50, $21.30 |
| Cow Tipper |
| Homemade organic tomato sauce, mozzarella, all-natural ground beef, black olives, parmesan & feta |
$9.60, $15.40, $19.60 |
| the Big Shindig |
| Homemade organic tomato sauce, organic mushrooms, mozzarella, organic green peppers, organic red onions, pepperoni, ground beef & black olives |
$10.60, $16.80, $21.60 |
| the Buddha |
| Extra virgin olive oil, organic garlic, organic baby spinach, sharp white cheddar, roma tomatoes, organic zucchini, kalamata olives, parmesan & feta |
$10.60, $16.80, $21.60 |
| Tricky Ricky |
| Homemade organic tomato sauce, organic mushrooms, mozzarella, organic yellow onions, organic green peppers, black olives & parmesan |
$9.60, $15.40, $19.60 |
| the Gus |
| Porcini mushroom oil, organic minced garlic, organic cremini mushrooms, organic portobellos, sharp white cheddar, parmesan & fontina |
$10.60, $16.80, $21.60 |
| Thai Bhat |
| Spicy peanut sauce, all-natural grilled chicken, organic garlic, chili pepper, organic baby corn, straw mushrooms, organic carrots, sharp white cheddar, parmesan, fresh ginger & scallions |
$11, $18, 23 |
| Pizza by the SLICE |
| Lilly's delicious Slices! Each is Made to Order and includes our homemade organic tomato sauce, independently farmed mozzarella & parmesan. Top each one of YOUR way from any of our 59 Toppings!
(Limited Availability on Weekends!) |
$2.3 each additional topping is $ .50 |
| Sergeant Scofflaw |
| Extra virgin olive oil, organic minced garlic, vine-ripened roma tomatoes, fresh mozzarella, parmesan & organic basil |
$10.60, $16.80, $21.60 |
| Sir Walter |
| Porcini mushroom oil, prosciutto di parma, smoked gouda, fresh organic garlic, organic mushrooms, mozzarella, parmesan & oregano |
$10.60, 16.80, 21.60 |
| Gluten Free Pies |
| Lilly's proudly serves a 10" gluten-free option for any of our pies. We hope you enjoy! |
$2 additional. |
|
| Bread Sticks |
| Four hand-rolled sticks covered with Parmesan and our House Spice Blend! Served with a side of our delicious, organic tomato sauce. |
$4 Add White Cheddar & Monterey Jack Cheeses $1.50 |
| Pita |
| A plethora of Vegan Pita slices served with our trio of homemade sauces - hummus, mango salsa & spinach artichoke dip. |
$5 Add Pico de Gallo, Minced Garlic & Parmesan $1.50 |
| Pigs in a Blanket |
| Handmade roll of authentic prosciutto di parma, canadian bacon, rosemary and sharp white cheddar. Served with ranch dressing. |
$8 |
| Hot Wings |
| A Baker's Dozen of our all natural wings oven baked in your choice of sauces: Homemade Atomic, Mild, Hot, Barbecue, or Sweet & Spicy Peanut.
Served with our homemade Blue Cheese dressing & Celery. |
$7 |
| Chili |
| Traditional meaty chili made right here from all-natural ground chuck and organic veggies. Served with crackers, monterey jack, and cilantro. |
$4 |
| Black Bean Soup (vegan) |
| A delicious bowl of organic & vegan veggies made right in our store. Served with crackers & cilantro. Mildy Spicy!
Sour cream available upon request. |
$4 |
| Stuffed Poblano Peppers |
| Two Grilled Poblano Peppers filled with our homemade stuffing of black beans, rosemary roasted potatoes, chilies & cheeses. Served with atomic sauce and cilantro. Allow for extra cooking time. |
$7 |
| Bruschetta |
| Five pieces of Lilly's dough topped with a sundried tomato pesto, fresh mozzarella, vine-ripened roma tomatoes, & organic basil. Served with balsamic vinaigrette. |
$7 |
| Stuffed Shrooms |
| Roasted mushrooms filled with monterey jack, pesto, grilled shrimp and bacon. Topped with fresh basil! |
$7 |
| Pretzel |
| Lilly's dough served as a pretzel. A delicious new option. Served with a side of our tomato sauce! |
$4 |
| Veggie Bake |
| Organic veggies oven roasted with our house blend of spices & parmesan. Served with fresh basil. Allow for extra cooking time. |
$6 |
| Meat Bake |
| Oven roasted meatballs, bacon, our tomato sauce, minced garlic, mozzarella, provolone & parmesan.
Served with fresh basil.
|
$8 |
|